If he has feelings for both then he should choose neither. He should be alone and sort that out thoroughly, flip flopping and triangles are done to death
I'd prefer Hope. I've already told it, but I'm really sick of all those ship swapping. I just want two lover that can stay togethers through the whole show. Even if I know it's something impossible for JP...
He Will Most Definitely Choose Hope Because I Believe Their Soul Mate's As I Believe The Same For Rafael And Josie I Just Want The Characters To Be Happy And I Think They Will Be Eventually