it needed blood from a Doppelganger or a more powerful creature for sure, you're forgetting that it was an immortality spell? to perform a spell like that needs a very large amount of magic it's not just any witch who performs it, it wasn't a spell to create werewolves if that's what you want to explain, even why the Hollow used death itself as a source of energy, which was strong enough to create the werewolves, the variation of Freya's blood or Tatia's blood was why it needed of a large amount of magic to perform the vampire creation spell, because every immortality spell needs a massive amount of magic to be able to be performed, Qetsyah used her blood or raw power anyway her magic was great enough for such a feat, if I'm not mistaken, they already said that drops of her blood were enough, Esther used the blood of Tatia and Lucien with the help of the ancestors and Vincent to cast the spell apparently used He had the blood of Freya's Firstborn, so it was said that Lucien knew about Dahlia, and surely he must have known the amount of magical power a Mikaelson Firstborn had.