“
Here's how it works. Ten stars representing ten of your friends who are going to perform for you. And at the end of each round, you have to tell us how you feel, and the truth orb will keep you honest.
”
— MG explains the rules of Salvatore Idol in Someplace Far Away From All This Violence
Salvatore Idol was a game show-like event that MG hosted in the attempt to get reach Hope Mikaelson and have her turn her humanity back on. Hope agreed to MG, Josie, and Cleo's request to hear them all out in exchange for all the weapons she needs to go after Triad. To prevent any physical violence, the event was bound with an unbreakable covenant spell. MG also gave her the Truth Sphere to keep her honest.
Event[]
- First Star
- Participant: Wade Rivers
- Performance: "When I first came to this school, I didn't really fit in with any of the factions, but I always really looked up to you, Hope, because you didn't care about fitting in. You were unique. And when I found out that I actually was a fairy..."
- Ruling: "Wayne, I'm gonna stop you right there because the only thing that I'm feeling is, um... irritation bordering on homicidal rage. [...] I also know that I was only nice to you because of Landon. Why don't you go sprout some of your ridiculous wings and go back to Fern Gully or wherever you're from?"
- Status: Destroyed
- Second Star
- Participant: Unknown
- Performance: Unknown
- Ruling: Unknown
- Status: Destroyed
- Third Star
- Participant: Unknown
- Performance: Unknown
- Ruling: Unknown
- Status: Destroyed
- Fourth Star
- Participant: Unknown
- Performance: Unknown
- Ruling: Unknown
- Status: Destroyed
- Fifth Star
- Participant: Unknown
- Performance: Unknown
- Ruling: Unknown
- Status: Destroyed
- Sixth Star
- Participant: Pedro
- Performance: "I'm not scared of you like everyone else. You taught me how to kick monster butt, and you helped me with all my art projects, so I made this for you. Because you are my Salvatore Idol."
- Ruling: "I feel like Pedro should have his fingers cut off and never make art again."
- Status: Destroyed
- Seventh Star
- Participant: Cleo Sowande (as Landon with the Illusion Ring)
- Performance: "I am not the real thing, but this letter is. He left it behind for you, Hope. "Dear Hope, if you're reading this, it means I'm dead, which, admittedly, sucks, but it's not all bad because that probably means you beat Malivore, which probably means you had to become the Tribrid, and I know you never wanted that, but it does mean you get to do what most of us only ever dream of. You get to live forever. Everything we talked about... backpacking through Europe, hiking up the Pacific coast... you now have all the time in the world to do those things. I know you feel like you're alone, but you're not. You have friends that love you. People that will never give up on you, no matter what. Don't pull away. My wish is for you to have a long, happy life, Hope. Do all the things I'll never get to. And wherever you go, remember that I'll always love you. Forever."
- Ruling: "I'm feeling something. Boredom. Yeah, that's what I'm feeling. It's Cleo, right? Fake Landons are kind of her thing. I should thank you. You pushed me to make the transition, but that also means that Landon's death is your fault. If not for all your secrets, this could have all been avoided."
- Status: Destroyed
- Eighth Star
- Participant: Ethan
- Performance: N/A
- Ruling: "I'm gonna guess you were gonna use some hokey sports metaphor. Jocks like you tend to find their identity in teams because you're completely unremarkable by yourself. So, pass."
- Status: Destroyed
- Ninth Star
- Participant: Finch Tarrayo (Substituted in for Josie)
- Performance: N/A
- Ruling: "You're up, Finch, since Josie won't come out to play. [...] Too bad. Time's up. You can take her place. Josie taught you not to be a lone wolf, which is really just a cover for your codependency."
- Status: Destroyed
- Tenth Star
- Participant: Milton Greasley
- Performance: N/A
- Ruling: "If Salvatore Idol were to be televised, you'd be canceled before the title card, so if this was your big idea, I give it zero stars. See? Game over."
- Status: Destroyed
Trivia[]
- Hope joked that if people were going to start to sing, she would turn Salvatore Idol into Survivor, an obvious nod to American Idol.
- Even after Salvatore Idol was ended, MG, Finch and Ethan, and Josie tried three additional methods to reach Hope's humanity. While MG talked to Hope, Finch and Ethan attempted to sedate Hope and drain her of blood, though end with Finch being knocked unconscious. Josie attempted to use her darker self to see what Hope was afraid of. After Hope defeated Dark Josie, Hope trapped her within the Therapy Box.
- In You Will Remember Me, Lizzie mocked the name of the event, calling it Salvatore's Got No Talent, another obvious nod to America's Got Talent.